Review: Litchenza Samuti and Chamasowa

Applicant	Water for People	Application ID:	5
Status:	Approved Accepted	Review Cycle end date:	2006-10-27

Application Rating and Comment Explanation

The rating and comment reflect the reviewer's opinion of the project's potential for success, though we need to see the diversity of the reviewers and their rating style across projects.

The rating is a number from 1 (Poor) to 10 (Excellent).

Note that it is difficult to compare applications due to their diversity, and therefore the comment provides a very important context to the number. It reflects the reviewer’s thoughts and recommendations regarding this application; why they feel this project will or will not be successful.

Application Ratings and Final Comments

Review By (only shown to PWX members) over 5 years ago

Rating: 8
Comment

i know nothing about the technology to be used in this project, I gather that perhaps an AfriDev pump is an african adaptation of the rope pump? or is it some other kind of pump? i do not know what a bore hole is nor have I ever hear of the use, or success or failure, of squat slabs. i don't even know if they have little houses around them. I support this project because of the detailed information about WFP's history and current operations in malawi , therefore I assume that this project grows out of experience; and also because I agree heartily that $25 per person is PR, not developmet finance.

Review By (only shown to PWX members) over 5 years ago

Rating: 10
Comment

very good overview - congratulations for your work! :)

Review By (only shown to PWX members) over 5 years ago

Rating: 9
Comment

Detailed application. Nice to see the outcomes that will be measured.

Summary Comment for Final Disposition

Visible to PWX members only

Application Summary

Applicant	:	Water for People
Status	:	Approved Accepted
Country	:	MALAWI (map)

Funding

Amount Funded	:	$59,232
Funded By:-
Blue Planet Network	:	$59,232
Funds Used	:	$59,232
Funds Available	:	$0

Project Summary of Application

Start Date	:	2006-04-20
Completion Date	:	2007-04-20
Date of Last Update	: