Review: Water System Rehabilitation Lupang Pangako Project

Applicant A Single Drop Application ID: 82
Status: Approved Accepted Review Cycle end date: 2008-01-05

Application Rating and Comment Explanation

The rating and comment reflect the reviewer's opinion of the project's potential for success, though we need to see the diversity of the reviewers and their rating style across projects.

The rating is a number from 1 (Poor) to 10 (Excellent).

Note that it is difficult to compare applications due to their diversity, and therefore the comment provides a very important context to the number. It reflects the reviewer’s thoughts and recommendations regarding this application; why they feel this project will or will not be successful.

Application Ratings and Final Comments

Review By (only shown to PWX members) about 4 years ago

Rating: 6
Comment

The project seems well designed but I would really like to see sanitation addressed as well, either by bringing in outside help, or by asking for additional resources.

Review By (only shown to PWX members) about 4 years ago

Rating: 6
Comment

See my detailed responses to this question in the Q&A section.

Review By (only shown to PWX members) about 4 years ago

Rating: 9
Comment

I like the idea of repairing/fixing broken or non-functioning systems even more than building the fanciest new water systems. I therefore like the idea and would be very happy to see it funded. All the best for implementation.

Review By (only shown to PWX members) about 4 years ago

Rating: 4
Comment

Explanation of project is very long, but for me not that clear and somewhat confusing.
Is implementation in 5 weeks feasable and realistic?
Do not find any information on the project on the website. I asked already for more transparant financial information on the website on dec 13 th, which was promised to be available by year end.

Review By (only shown to PWX members) about 4 years ago

Rating: 7
Comment

This promises to be a good project. Just the newness and lack of familiarity with the org is a small concern - one which time and projects will alleviate.

Summary Comment for Final Disposition

Visible to PWX members only

Application Summary

Applicant :   A Single Drop
Status : Approved Accepted
Country : PHILIPPINES (map)

Funding

Amount Funded :   $3,000
Funded By:-
Blue Planet Network : $3,000
Funds Used
: $3,000
Funds Available
: $0

Project Summary of Application

Start Date : 2008-03-03
Completion Date : 2008-04-10
Date of Last Update :