: Construction of model ECOSAN toilets for the women SHG members of Vathalaikadu village.

Applicant Ekoventure Plan ID: 233
Status: approved_accepted Review Cycle end date: 2009-08-29

Discussion Forum

By El Porvenir Posted on Mon 27 Jul 2009, almost 17 years ago

Hi,

I have a number of questions about ECOSAN toilets based on the video on YouTube (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gPummZRR2Cg). Are the ones you are building the same as this?

1. How is the bag of fecal material removed from the toilet? What will the family do with it? Is there a cultural taboo about handling human waste?

2. What happens if other things fall in the toilet? Does it affect the toilet?

3. How long do these toilets typically last?

4. What keeps the material moving? Solar, wind, electricity?

5. The video also mentions that there can be low counts of harmful pathogens. Have you seen this with the other 62 ECOSAN toilets you've built? If so, how have you dealt with it?

Thank you,
Jenna Saldana, El Porvenir

By Ekoventure Posted on Mon 27 Jul 2009, almost 17 years ago

Dear Jenna Saldana

The ECOSAN toilets that we are promoting is different from the one that you are mentioning. The video at the site

http://videosearch.rediff.com/video_play.php?id=101708956&query=ecosan&val=http%3A%2F%2Fyoutube.com%2F%3Fv%3D4J5tj7nxnFM

is the same with slight modifications in the pan model.

Kindly see the leaflet attached in the profile of Ekoventure for details of the ECOSAN toilets that we promote.

Even if other things fall it doesn't affect the toilet.

the movement of material (faeces) - is directed to the chamber and doesn't involve any energy.

The chamber is kept closed for nearly six months and by that time mostly the harmful pathogens are killed. As the toilets that we have constructed are in use only for the past 6-8 months, we have not experienced. In another 4-6 months we will be removing the first chamber with decomposed faeces.

But we have visited ECOSAN toilets in other parts of Tamilnadu (Trichy, Tuticorin) where they are using the decomposed faeces as manure and did not face any problems.

By El Porvenir Posted on Sat 08 Aug 2009, almost 17 years ago

Seeing the pictures is helpful to know what these will look like, but are these completed? Is there no seat to the toilet?

By Ekoventure Posted on Mon 10 Aug 2009, almost 17 years ago

Dear Jenna Saldana,

The ECOSAN toilets are Indian and are not of western type.
We have uploaded a pdf file (in the application) with pictures taken 2 days back from our earlier project where we have constructed 62 toliets.

regards

Pushpalatha

Community Led Total Sanitation

By Team Blue Posted on Mon 10 Aug 2009, almost 17 years ago

In addition to the well-planned promotion of well-designed ECOSAN toilets, has the Community Led Total Sanitation (CLTS) approach been considered to be included in the proposed program?

If not, it should be, as it has apparently been quite successful in India, when properly carried out and implemented by trained and experienced trainers.

Community Led Total Sanitation

By Ekoventure Posted on Tue 11 Aug 2009, almost 17 years ago

Yes, the Community led Total Sanitation approach will be included. We have experienced trainers on Sanitation aspects and one of our staff has training on “Capacity Building for Ecological Sanitation in India” from 12th to 22nd May 2008 at MJP Research and Training Centre, Nashik, Maharashtra organized by Ecosan Services Foundation.

regards

Pushpalatha

Comment and query

By Project Well Posted on Sun 02 Aug 2009, almost 17 years ago

Faster the communities and farmers accept the idea of the use of feces as manure better for all. Require rapid action in building public awareness, in both, rural and urban areas. With change in the design with raised platforms (like commodes) on either side of a bidet, for washing and urinating would be ideal. It would be costlier than traditional toilets but we all need to correct our priorities for health and environment. Manufactures need to start producing and promoting them. Anything that is used by city people will be faster adopted by villagers.

Pictures of a few ecosan toilets that are in operation would be great to see how easy they can be maintained with minimum care. What would be the annual cost of maintenance?

If there was no fowl smell in excreta there would not have been any problem with handling feces, Removing the cover before every use would be repelling. Is anything being used in the toilet for the smell or ash takes care of it? If so, this information should be highlighted that there is minimum smell in such toilets. What kind of ash is used, wood or cowdung, or both?

Thank you. All the best.

Comment and query

By Ekoventure Posted on Sun 02 Aug 2009, almost 17 years ago

Dear Hira-Smith,

Thanks for your queries.

It is sure that it requires rapid action in building public awareness about the ECOSAN toilets. It took us nearly 4 months in our earlier project (Green Post Tsunami Action) to convince and select 62 beneficiaries. We conducted a series of awareness meetings, projected video films, organised exposure visits for 300 women and men to the existing ECOSAN toilets in use, to finalise 62 beneficiaries. In the present project area, we have conducted awareness meetings and projected video films to the women SHG members in their monthly meetings. Hence, we feel that it would be organising an exposure visit to ECOSAN toilets at Trichy would finally convince the women in taking up the construction of ECOSAN toilets.

We will upload some of the ECOSAN toilets that are in use in the project application.

Ash of either wood or cowdung is used. Properly maintained toilets doesn't need anything extra to be void of smell. Ash takes care of it.

We tried with Effective Microorganism (E.M) in some households and the results are encouraging. We supplied Bokashi (meaning: Fermented food) - Sawdust fermented with Effective Microorganism to the households.

E.M is a mixture of beneficial microorganisms used in the fields of Hugiene, Solid waste management, composting, treatment of wastewater, bioremediation of polluted water bodies and soils. For further info: please contact www.mapleorgtech.com

regards
Pushpalatha

Comment and query

By Project Well Posted on Mon 03 Aug 2009, almost 17 years ago

Hello Pushpalatha,
Cool! informative. Thanks. Wish it was that easy to implement and we, who work in the field, know how hard it is. Love your method of approach by showing video films. Why don't all the TV channels in the world run one minute adds on promoting such important issues I wonder as they run the adds for drinks and burgers, that cause more health problems instead of preventing. Best Wishes. Meera


Application Summary

Applicant :   Ekoventure
Status : approved_accepted
Country : INDIA Map

Funding

Amount Funded :   $4,354
Funded By:-
Blue Planet Network : $4,354
Funds Used
: $4,354
Funds Available
: $0

Projects Summary of Application

Number of Projects : 3
Overall Start Date : TODO!
Overall Completion Date : TODO!
Date of Last Update : 2012-12-08