What Users Are Saying About PWX
Watershed Organization Trust, India
What I saw in PWX took my breath away.
I am truly surprised that the world of NGOs, their partners and funding agencies have not grabbed this tool and run.
I was also moved by your vision, the power of the tool and its rooting in collaboration.
East Meets West, Vietnam
It is clear that there is a broad range of knowledge, understanding and experience among those who submitted proposals.
I think that people who have more experience in the water development business have an obligation to help tutor and encourage
those who have less experience, as we are all trying to do the right thing in the long run, right?
Barefoot College, India
The drawbacks of the current funding model is that it to too patronizing and it presumes that we need the knowledge, skills and wisdom of the North.
The track record over the last two decades have shown that the solutions being offered by the North have been expensive, wasteful and indeed by and large they have failed.
What we need is a more active, equal, respectful South-South exchange.
Gram Vikas, India
PWX does away with the bureaucracies involved in the conventional method and is of course transparent, gives scope for peer review, is very effective in terms of resource use and provides cross exchange and learning.
For an implementing organization, such platforms do help in putting forth ideas in succinct manner and saves much of time and resources in putting up lengthy proposals.
My strong hope is that other organizations see the potential of this network to shine a light on what is working in the water sector ... so that we all can do a better job while getting a fuller picture of what is working long-term.
Watershed Organization Trust, India
PWX is one of the innovative and excellent methods of sanctioning the project proposals through peer group assessment.
NGOs have the opportunity to know more details of the excellent work carried out by the different NGOs.
One gets an opportunity to know and interact with different partner NGOs of the world engaged in providing safe drinking water tot needy communities
Through PWX we had an opportunity to learn/know the different appropriate low cost and affordable technologies being used by partner NGOs in different parts of the world.
Some of these technologies could be replicated in our areas too.
PWX system avoids the administrative expenses additional requirement of human resource by the funding agency.
In normal practice, the projects are submitted to the funding agency for the approval or sanction.
The explanations and additional information is provided by the NGO to the funding agency, but the information and knowledge is useful only to the funding agency.
But under the new developed PWX system the project proposals are scrutinized and assessed by the all the partner NGOs.
The PWX system is easy and computer friendly to operate.
The progress reports and additional information of the project, photographs can be disseminated through the system.
PWX is an innovative way to address the issue of how a small organization can administer
a great deal of funding without having to hire a huge staff.
PWX is straightforward to use, and the review process shows that it also has potential to
serve as a forum for knowledge sharing and peer mentoring.
Challenges will be keeping the review process streamlined and requirements reasonable.
Oywa A Solar Support Group, Kenya
PWX has the best approach to analyzing proposals in a very transparent manner.
We thank the entire PWX team and Blue Planet Run for the unique initiative of scrutinizing applications and
ensuring that even inexperienced groups like Oywa get a chance to participate in the process.
We have really learnt a lot and expect to learn more with your continued support.
We only have some suggestions to enable rural and remote groups like Oywa to meet their deadlines.
These include issues like enabling groups to acquire computers or laptops.
This would enable them to communicate with you in good time.
It would also mean the groups will spend less time in travelling to towns like Kisumu where such services are available.
Joining PWX paid unexpected dividends.
The responses to my proposal posed probing questions that caused me to delve deeper into some of the water project planning.
Our focus in looking at water projects has expanded to
consider the economic, environmental, political and sustainability issues more deeply.
In evaluating grants proposed by other organizations, I learned about ways of structuring future grants
The experience was very helpful in many ways and I was happy to receive funding for one of our projects.
El Porvenir, Nicaragua
The application requirements of some funders,
e.g. C--- Canada, are so onerous and time consuming that our organization would have to take three or four staff members off of their usual work in
project development, reforestation and health education, for at least a month, just to fill out all the forms and give all the workshops required
in order to submit an application. Is this a good use of our resources?
Is there an alternative funding source which does not require excessive forms, paperwork, staff time taken away from our real work?
El Porvenir, Nicaragua
My impressions of PWX are on the whole positive.
I certainly understand the point of view about the difficulty of evaluating projects where we have no experience; however, I think it is a good system,
not too overwhelming with details, easy to use, and provides some good opportunities for sharing knowledge between partners.
A downside was that not all the partners participated equally, and for example one of the projects I reviewed, they never answered my questions and
I had to mark their project low, in part because of my doubts, but in part because of lack of information.
I hope more people will find the time to participate.
Carolyn Crowley Meub,
Pure Water for the World
Getting people to discuss lessons learned, as PWX is doing, is like trying to 'herd cats'! Many people do not like to talk about failures or disappointments but they are a reality and they are really the only way forward. Good luck PWX!
Director Programmes Arghyam
In India, sanitation efforts have failed miserably and everyone is trying to change behaviour at the beneficiary level.
PWX is trying to change institutional behaviour change in the funding and implementing communities - analogous challenges. Its an important question: can the sector cause the impact without changing internally first?
What Water Authorities Are Saying About PWX
This site has created a real breakthrough approach, providing the coordination, information and evaluation
so critical for the success of water improvement projects.
This community also provides easy access to best practices, helping water groups grow stronger and
more effective through collaboration and peer review.
U.S. Congressman, 3rd District, Oregon
Co-Sponsor of the Paul Simon 2005 Water For The Poor Act
and 2009 Water For The World Act
Dr. Peter Gleick
What I've seen so far looks tremendous. I've seen nothing else like it, and think it offers serious potential for improving transparency, information available to users, and the ability to understand what really works in the real world.
President, Pacific Institute
Author of the biennial series: The World's Water
BPR's initiative to use a peer review process to assess and approve water and sanitation
projects is bold in its conception and inclusive in its method.
Bringing in organizations and individuals in different parts of the world to the process of
project selection and approval is both transparent and cost effective.
Other organizations supporting water and sanitation projects may well have something to learn from this approach.
Vice Chairman, Asia Pacific Water Forum
Former CEO, WaterAid
The PWX concept is powerful in its simplicity and reach.
There are painfully few approaches that have both the appeal and effectiveness of PWX.
UC San Diego Institute on Global Conflict & Cooperation
Advisor, Red Cross
Former Senior Global Technology Partner, Boston Consulting Group
PWX has shown that it is possible to scale and replicate community-based water
projects around the world – this is hugely important when one of the major barriers to community – to – community learning has been cost and distance.
Energy and Resources Group, UC Berkeley
PWX nurtures water leaders, creates knowledge and serves society across the globe. That's adding value indeed.
Dr. Allan Smith
Donation without evaluation is fraud
Director, Arsenic Health Effects Research Program, University of California, Berkeley
Other Quotes Relevant to PWX
R. Buckminster Fuller
You never change things by fighting the existing reality.
To change something, build a new model that makes the existing model obsolete.
First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win.
In the long run, many small, power-efficient and cooperating systems are going to replace the so far used, heavy weighted ones.
EcoSort Developer, Karlsruhe Institute of Technology
There is an evil tendency underlying all our technology -
the tendency to do what is reasonable even when it isn't any good.
Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance
Technology is dominated by two types of people:
those who understand what they do not manage, and those who manage what they do not understand.
Programming today is a race between software engineers striving to build bigger and better idiot-proof programs, and the Universe trying to produce bigger and better idiots. So far, the Universe is winning.
The Wizardry Compiled
Martin Luther King, Jr.
Philanthropy is commendable, but it must not cause the philanthropist to overlook the circumstances of economic injustice which make philanthropy necessary.
Rajesh's Corollary 1: In solving problems in the short-term we must also, even if in small measure, address the systemic issues which caused the problem in the first case.
Rajesh's Corollary 2: Philanthropists need not organize themselves and operate in the same way as the organizations that create the injustice.
The water cycle connects us all, and from water we can learn the path of peace and the way of freedom. We can learn how to transcend water wars created by greed, waste, and injustice, which create scarcity in our water-abundant planet. We can work with the water cycle to reclaim water abundance. We can work together to create water democracies. And if we build democracy, we will build peace.
We cannot solve our problems with the same thinking we used when we created them.
Rajesh's Corollary: People addressing humanitarian and environmental problems should not think, act, and organize in the same way as the institutions that helped create these issues, if they are serious about solving them.
Richard Saul Wurman
Everyone spoke of an information overload, but what there was in fact was a non-information overload.
If you want to be incrementally better: Be competitive.
If you want to be exponentially better: Be cooperative.
We need to stand firm about the real complexity of biological systems and not let policy makers push us into simplistic answers (to tackle climate change). We need conservation measures that don’t rely on impossible precision.
Associate Professor, Integrative Biology, University of Texas
Member of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC)
Rajesh's Corollary: Solutions to water and sanitation are complex - involving people's perceptions and requiring behavior change. We cannot and should not simplify them nor quantify them precisely.
To build toilets is easy, but to shift people's mind and hearts is the real work.
Software is more important than hardware.
You can have 10,000 explanations for failure, but no good explanations for success.
Author of The Alchemist
Rajesh's Corollary: A forum to showcase and discuss failures without fear is urgently required. This will prove more helpful and effective than having another list of 'best practices'.
The status quo is a very powerful opiate ... it’s very hard to make yourself change.
Founder and Chairman, Interface
Remember that failure is an event, not a person.
Motivational Speaker, Trainer, Author